Banner Contest Vote

[Kingofrunes]

I Vote A.

It looks the most appealing to me.

Entry C could work pending on what characters are rotated in. As Entry C is now, it looks incredibly plain.

Entry B I don't like at all. Way more bland than Entry C

[Kueh]

I can't really decide between A and C, but I'm kind of leaning toward C, cause I have bad memories of Filia.

[Kenny?]

C :)

[Cynic]

I'm going to have to go for C. Though the text could be a bit bigger and positioned a bit differently, it's still my favorite overall.

[Time]

I like C, the character swapping could be really really cool, I agree the right side of it should be left alone though, and I feel it would grow on me, but the negative space in the middle seems a little large.

[Seviraph]

Entry C


B looked nice too, but I hardly noticed Nao, so if that was picked, maybe a version where she wasn't so far to the right would've looked better (applies to any character really for that one)

but definitely C

[BobYoMeowMeow]

C's a good choice
not perfect (might need a little adjustmustments)

[Papaya Pok Pok]

I vote entry A.

Entry B was too bland, everything looks boring (No offense)

Entry C was nice, still bland though and the text is meh. I don't like where it's located or the style of the font.

Entry A was the best. It really stick out although, the font should be changed to something less "cluttered"

[Hitaki]

I would like Banner A the most since it's not using Nao nor Lorna and Pan, which would make it more unique in a way, but I'm bothered by the art. I'm not saying the art is bad. Just that it bothers me that it's not mabi-esque, and I feel that it's more someone's own signature than a mabinogi themed banner.

I've seen the Banner Kitae made for the contest, and I think it would go great if you overlayed it on top of the banners. Banner B for example has tons of open space in the middle, and would be the perfect spot to slap on a gif.

In the end, I'm not voting on any of them, rather just laying down my opinion.

[╔╦╗╒╕║╒╕]

You can't cycle all three of them, Osay?

Then it wouldn't be a contest.



I like entry C the most, that would be my vote. It's the most artistic looking I guess, it also doesn't hurt your eyes or stand out too much which I feel A and B would.