Most Underrated/Overrated Shows?

[Spartaaaaa]

What do you all think the most underrated and/or overrated shows are?

Off the top of my head:

Underrated

Last Exile: Fam the Silver Wing

 Spoiler:

(get rid of Fam and it would actually be really good)

11eyes

 Spoiler:

(it wasn't that bad)

C3

 Spoiler:

(get rid of the ecchi and it would actually be kind of interesting)

Black Rock Shooter

 Spoiler:

(forced drama is pretty fun to watch)

Haruhi Suzumiya Second Season

 Spoiler:

(skip endless eight, and the rest of the episodes are just as good as anything from first season)

Overrated

Five Centimeters per Second

 Spoiler:

(felt way too rushed)

Kuroshitsuji Second Season

 Spoiler:

(convoluted mess of a show)

Kara no Kyoukai

 Spoiler:

(you know there's a problem when it takes four whole movies before it starts making any sense)

[Paul]

Most overrated this season. Fate/Zero.

I'm enjoying the show but Hyouka probably only got as much reception as it does right now because it's KyoAni.

Underrated anime this season. Note I saide ANIME, not the manga. Medaka Box.

Random Anime Watcher Whose Never Read The Manga: "Another student council anime with a huge cleavage female lead? Fanservice? Eh, I'll watch a couple episodes and drop it."

[Spartaaaaa]

Underrated anime this season. Note I saide ANIME, not the manga. Medaka Box.

Random Anime Watcher Whose Never Read The Manga: "Another student council anime with a huge cleavage female lead? Fanservice? Eh, I'll watch a couple episodes and drop it."

Does it actually get good later? Does it move beyond the cheap fanservice and get a plot?

[Paul]

Does it actually get good later? Does it move beyond the cheap fanservice and get a plot?

First of all, I'll say this, it's a BATTLE SHOUNEN. You know, where they fight? Second, considering the anime only has 12 episode, we won't get anywhere unless there's more seasons.

The opening shows a little of the foreshadowing for fight that'll happen in the next couple episodes but that fight won't be as good as the fights that happen after the arc.

Foreshadowing picture from the opening.

 Spoiler:

The anime won't get to this point (below) but the series itself is quite bloody.

Scene from the end of a certain arc which is the arc after the anime.

 Spoiler:

Also, the series hasn't shown the best character yet... Kumagawa.

[GODZILLA]

Underrated

Ōban Star-Racers
ThunderCats (the new one)

Overrated

Full Metal Alchemist.


That's all I can think of right now.

[Second]

Underrated
Guin Saga
Kurenai
A bunch of old stuff

Overrated
anything by key
anything by kyoani