Quote from Shanghai;245209:
That's if you get a critical though. Usually SM mobs have too much protection it's hard to get a 30% critical rate... Unless you have enchants of course.
put it this way its the same with melee correct...? yes...
well how many people can boast 8500-8800 crit smash?
no 1 i know of :/
so even if it doesnt do 8500-8800 either way crit is affected by prot except magic now since the whole thing is based on alchemy either way HB will do more w/o a crit then smash would and even then.. freeze then heat buster is even more effective but less reliable because of a potential failure but of course not many would risk it mid fight (its more a starter move)