Quote from Armi;367464:
edit: I chose dignified over elementalist because of the low deviation from alche path as well as ease of obtaining. The difference is 1~3 crit depending on roll.
It is also possible to drop suprising for tidal, as most hm mobs do not have prot over 40% but I aimed a little higher for boss monsters as well.
I'm all for planning for the bosses.
After a night to think about this... I would replace the ripple on the hat with burning (not flaming), make the cylinder 0~2 crit upgrades and replace both surprisings for transparents. In addition, I would R-Type lvl 3 the cylinder and wear the chain cylinder master title. That would give you a +117 water damage with max crit, while maximizing dmg per second.
While S-type technically gives a couple more dmg per second if you spam, R-types are cheaper and are better if you maximize dmg per second by charging to 5.