Banner Contest Vote

• User495 wrote on 2012-05-13 15:32
  Entry C
  
  
  B looked nice too, but I hardly noticed Nao, so if that was picked, maybe a version where she wasn't so far to the right would've looked better (applies to any character really for that one)
  
  but definitely C
• BobYoMeowMeow wrote on 2012-05-13 15:37
  C's a good choice
  not perfect (might need a little adjustmustments)
• MiniSoda wrote on 2012-05-13 15:37
  I vote entry A.
  
  Entry B was too bland, everything looks boring (No offense)
  
  Entry C was nice, still bland though and the text is meh. I don't like where it's located or the style of the font.
  
  Entry A was the best. It really stick out although, the font should be changed to something less "cluttered"
• Misaka wrote on 2012-05-13 15:38
  I would like Banner A the most since it's not using Nao nor Lorna and Pan, which would make it more unique in a way, but I'm bothered by the art. I'm not saying the art is bad. Just that it bothers me that it's not mabi-esque, and I feel that it's more someone's own signature than a mabinogi themed banner.
  
  I've seen the Banner Kitae made for the contest, and I think it would go great if you overlayed it on top of the banners. Banner B for example has tons of open space in the middle, and would be the perfect spot to slap on a gif.
  
  In the end, I'm not voting on any of them, rather just laying down my opinion.
• M wrote on 2012-05-13 15:39

  Quote from Rin;862657:

  You can't cycle all three of them, Osay?

  
  
  Then it wouldn't be a contest.
  
  
  
  I like entry C the most, that would be my vote. It's the most artistic looking I guess, it also doesn't hurt your eyes or stand out too much which I feel A and B would.
• Rin wrote on 2012-05-13 15:48

  Quote from Cucurbita;862660:

  [Image: http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v608/KitaeK27/tumblr_lej1v68PlH1qdlkgg.gif]

  
  
  I think he's being picky about the rest of the site design, which he'll work on depending on the banner itself.

  
  
  

  Quote from Maia;862691:

  Then it wouldn't be a contest.

  
  
  How true.
  
  I don't have a vote, because it'd be a terribly and absolutely biased one.
• MareneCorp wrote on 2012-05-13 15:54
  I find C the most appealing because of that background, but the left side seems a bit too... "empty".
  
  Also, should make a thread in BR for the people that don't look.
• Cucurbita wrote on 2012-05-13 16:16

  Quote from Misaka;862690:

  I've seen the Banner Kitae made for the contest, and I think it would go great if you overlayed it on top of the banners. Banner B for example has tons of open space in the middle, and would be the perfect spot to slap on a gif.

  
  
  The left side of C works too.
  
  Frankly I don't even care about the prize or winning anymore [S]to an extent[/S]. I just think the gif rotation is way too fun to give up. Aren't we all about fun here at nation?
• Cannibal wrote on 2012-05-13 16:37
  What's this "fun" you speak of?
  
  But I'm curious as to what you're talking about anyway...
• Oizen wrote on 2012-05-13 16:42
  Are all of these just official mabi art with text?
  
  
  ._.
• Cucurbita wrote on 2012-05-13 16:56

  Quote from OizenX;862725:

  Are all of these just official mabi art with text?
  
  
  ._.

  
  
  The fact that you thought A was official mabi art shows the wonderful amount of skill the artist holds.
  
  *insert thumbs up here*
• Okami wrote on 2012-05-13 16:57
  They're all wonderful, but I'm going to have to go with C
• ♪ wrote on 2012-05-13 17:13

  Quote from Misaka;862690:

  I would like Banner A the most since it's not using Nao nor Lorna and Pan, which would make it more unique in a way, but I'm bothered by the art. I'm not saying the art is bad. Just that it bothers me that it's not mabi-esque, and I feel that it's more someone's own signature than a mabinogi themed banner.
  
  I've seen the Banner Kitae made for the contest, and I think it would go great if you overlayed it on top of the banners. Banner B for example has tons of open space in the middle, and would be the perfect spot to slap on a gif.
  
  In the end, I'm not voting on any of them, rather just laying down my opinion.

  
  Seriously A.
  
  Every mabi fan site and their mother has Nao or Lorna and Pan
  it would make the banner stand out more.
• Osayidan wrote on 2012-05-13 17:19

  Quote from ♪;862739:

  Seriously A.
  
  Every mabi fan site and their mother has Nao or Lorna and Pan
  it would make the banner stand out more.

  
  
  Keep in mind if C wins I'm editing out lorna/pan to make that corner empty, and have a bunch of character cut-outs in rotation in that area instead.
• Kayate wrote on 2012-05-13 17:24
  Right now I'm liking entry C.