I'll update the list to support new weapons/players. The top three weapons in each category from every server will be listed. "Legitimacy" matters not. Please refrain from quoting or copying the inital post. You can refer anyone.
[Image: http://img546.imageshack.us/img546/1430/swordh.png]
[SPOILER="Spoiler"]
Awards
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png](40-44 social)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png](45-49 social)
[Image: http://i40.tinypic.com/1zfttl5.png](50 social)
Fast 3-Hit
Dagger
Alexina: Zippity - Damage (24-41), Critical (32%), Social (21)
Mari: Melka - Damage (19-30), Critical (30%), Social (16)
Tarlach:
Ruairi: Alenilee - Damage (25-48), Critical (35%), Social (32)
Viseo's Bronze Mirror Blade
Alexina:
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi: Nithiel - Damage (30-45), Critical (38%), Social (18)
Normal 2-Hit
Liberty Saber
Alexina:
1. Orekah - Damage (79-154), Critical (47%)
2. Aoko - Damage (48-101), Critical (31%), Social (21)
Mari:
1. erosanin - Damage (91-180), Critical (52%), Social (50)
[Image: http://i40.tinypic.com/1zfttl5.png]
2. Nghi - Damage (45-99), Critical (33%), Social (20)
Tarlach: Mikizuko - Damage (83-168), Critical (48%), Social (46)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png]
Ruairi:
1. Johndeweyboy - Damage (69-178), Critical (46%), Social (46)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
2. Subete - Damage (53-111), Critical (33%), Social (25)
Normal 3-Hit
Short Sword
Alexina: Kaino - Damage (28-40), Critical (5%), Social (20)
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
Fluted Short Sword
Alexina:
Mari: ZXHiryu - Damage (28-46), Critical (11%), Social (19)
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
Slow 2-Hit
Broad Sword
Alexina:
Mari:
Tarlach: tsukkz - Damage (42-89), Critical (21%), Social (21)
Ruairi:
Gladius
Alexina: Chaosruler - Damage (54-90), Critical (34%), Social (22)
Mari:
1. CCo - Damage (99-171), Critical (48%), Social (50)
[Image: http://i40.tinypic.com/1zfttl5.png]
2. Sayo - Damage (92-171), Critical (48%), Social (46)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png]
3. FLCL - Damage (92-158), Critical (40%)
Tarlach:
1. Zeru - Damage (87-161), Critical (45%), Social (41)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
2. Chengzi - Damage (92-160), Critical (40%), Social (41)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
3. Anemia - Damage (92-154), Critical (40%), Social (39)
Ruairi: Borunks - Damage (70-123), Critical (35%), Social (30)
Bastard Sword
Alexina:
1. Flopsy - Damage (39-139), Critical (12%), Social (31)
2. Kratos27 - Damage (40-138), Critical (11%), Social (28)
3. Superkim0 - Damage (40-128), Critical (10%)
Mari:
1. Lene - Damage (59-189), Critical (19%), Social (50)
[Image: http://i40.tinypic.com/1zfttl5.png]
2. Nevi - Damage (58-178), Critical (18%)
3. Hitokirykira - Damage (50-172), Critical (15%)
Tarlach: Wintrail - Damage (32-102), Critical (10%), Social (21)
Ruairi:
1. Lord - Damage (48-178), Critical (17%)
2. Northic - Damage (56-163), Critical (15%), Social (36)
Battle Sword
Alexina: Willi096 - Damage (46-69), Critical (34%), Social (21)
Mari: Ausar - Damage (30-42), Critical (32%), Social (1)
Ruairi:
Tarlach:
Falcata
Alexina:
1. Liseli - Damage (54-96), Critical (37%), Social (25)
2. Eddward - Damage (35-91), Critical (33%), Social (19)
Mari:
Ruairi:
Tarlach:
Hooked Cutlass
Alexina:
1. jake69 - Damage (109-175), Critical (61%), Social (47)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png]
2. bigpud - Damage (100-163), Critical (58%)
3. Vael - Damage (100-165), Critical (56%)
Mari:
1. Relick - Damage (83-152), Critical (54%), Social (33)
2. kingofrunes - Damage (80-146), Critical (54%), Social (34)
Ruairi: Kamina7 - Damage (64-124), Critical (53%), Social (28)
Tarlach:
Wakizashi
Alexina:
1. Xandrah - Damage (65-135), Critical (31%)
2. Akami - Damage (38-94), Critical (21%), Social (21)
Mari: Kageryuu - Damage (22-56), Critical (20%), Social (15)
Tarlach: Lamm - Damage (61-157), Critical (36%), Social (41)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
Ruairi:
Muramasa
Alexina:
1. Talonboy - Damage (52-143), Critical (35%)
2. nameless07 - Damage (47-120), Critical (35%), Social (30)
Mari:
1. Calisto - Damage (63-184), Critical (49%), Social (48)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png]
2. Kenero - Damage (48-163), Critical (37%), Social (36)
3. Linainverse - Damage (61-156), Critical (43%)
Tarlach:
1. Kakashi7 - Damage (56-174), Critical (47%), Social (43)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
2. Leidolf - Damage (63-161), Critical (42%), Social (41)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
Ruairi:
1. Sakuranbou - Damage (??-181), Critical (49%), Social (44)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
2. Thienn - Damage (64-159), Critical (42%), Social (42)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
3. Northic - Damage (55-153), Critical (40%), Social (38)
Very Slow 1-Hit
Machete
Alexina:
1. Kaon - Damage (87-200), Critical (12%), Social (30)
2. Aothis - Damage (67-148), Critical (7%)
3. Zippity - Damage (63-140), Critical (7%), Social (18)
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi: Saerah - Damage (89-199), Critical (9%), Social (28)
Very Slow 2-Hit
Two-handed Sword
Alexina: Cerpe - Damage (87-215), Critical (15%)
Mari:
1. Kurawado - Damage (104-233), Critical (19%), Social (50)
[Image: http://i40.tinypic.com/1zfttl5.png]
2. Chillz
Tarlach: Buuddha - Damage (98-223), Critical (17%), Social (41)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
Ruairi:
Claymore
Alexina:
1. Dvirus - Damage (90-134), Critical (23%)
2. Masakan - Damage (73-108), Critical (23%)
Mari:
1. Idelisa - Damage (123-189), Critical (29%)
2. Aiyas - Damage (70-103), Critical (21%), Social (18)
Tarlach:
Ruairi: Ruelf - Damage (127-194), Critical (29%), Social (36)
Dragon Blade
Alexina:
1. Valkyrion95 - Damage (102-157), Critical (25%), Social (32)
2. Azuka - Damage (82-131), Critical (15%), Social (21)
Mari: Xeph - Damage (134-209), Critical (28%), Social (44)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
Tarlach:
1. Tammie - Damage (141-209), Critical (28), Social (45)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png]
2. Mizoku - Damage (130-203), Critical (28), Social (41)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
Ruairi:
Dustin Silver Knight Sword
Alexina:
1. Jaq - Damage (103-242), Critical (37%)
2. Avartia - Damage (86-196), Critical (26%)
3. Valencian - Damage (39-132), Critical (27%), Social (22)
Mari: Elegants - Damage (105-224), Critical (32%), Social (41)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
Tarlach:
Ruairi: Amateras - Damage (30-90), Critical (24%), Social (12)
Masamune
Alexina:
Mari:
Tarlach: Bokku - Damage (109-214), Critical (40%), Social (40)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
Ruairi: NARUT0 - Damage (115-220), Critical (44%), Social (48)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png]
Katana
Alexina:
1. djorange - Damage (101-174), Critical (39%)
2. Toshiro2010 - Damage (65-130), Critical (22%), Social (21)
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
Glory Sword
Alexina:
1. Zarozian - Damage (64-125), Critical (45%)
2. Kardis - Damage (32-82), Critical (43%)
Mari:
Tarlach: Frogstar - Damage (107-204), Critical (48%), Social (36)
Ruairi:
Dragon Fang
Alexina:
1. willykatana - Damage (123-258), Critical (38%), Social (50)
[Image: http://i40.tinypic.com/1zfttl5.png]
2. Zerofreedom - Damage (30-104), Critical (26%), Social (19)
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
Highlander Claymore
Alexina: Akutare - Damage (68-137), Critical (22%), Social (25)
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
[/SPOILER]
[Image: http://puu.sh/5daC2.jpg]
[SPOILER="Spoiler"]
Awards
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png](40-44 social)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png](45-49 social)
[Image: http://i40.tinypic.com/1zfttl5.png](50 social)
Normal 3-Hit
Ruyuefeixue's Butterfly Fan
Alexina:
1. Taegryn - Damage (15-51), Critical (10%)
2. Coy - Damage (12-43), Critical (11%)
Mari: Ceui - Damage (23-85), Critical (12%), Social (22)
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
Wooden Stick
Alexina:
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi: rashness - Damage (23-77), Critical (13%), Social (19)
Slow 2-Hit
Warhammer
Alexina:
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi: Unknowing - Damage (37-149), Critical (15%), Social (31)
Mace
Alexina:
Mari:
1. Kannaa - Damage (31-171), Critical (8%)
2. Mirreth - Damage (30-163), Critical (6%), Social (32)
3. Furrycookies - Damage (32-163), Critical (8%), Social (33)
Tarlach: Joyjason - Damage (22-126), Critical (4%), Social (25)
Ruairi: Eirinn - Damage (19-96), Critical (6%), Social (23)
Iron Mace
Alexina:
1. Fullfocus - Damage (27-194), Critical (8%), Social (36)
2. Hrungnir - Damage (23-163), Critical (7%), Social (28)
3. Chopz - Damage (18-160), Critical (6%), Social (26)
Mari:
1. Benier - Damage (35-235), Critical (9%), Social (44)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
2. Thrower - Damage (28-200), Critical (8%), Social (37)
3. Elesia - Damage (22-155), Critical (7%)
Tarlach:
1. Brandonsmall - Damage (37-233), Critical (8%), Social (46)
2. Chiien - Damage (28-200), Critical (7%), Social (36)
Ruairi:
1. Mycelium - Damage (38-236), Critical (9%), Social (46)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png]
2. BIassreiter - Damage (30-204), Critical (8%), Social (37); Iron Mace
Francisca
Alexina: pejic2 - Damage (29-106), Critical (30%)
Mari: Allouetta - Damage (31-116), Critical (30%), Social (16)
Tarlach:
Ruairi: Partisan - Damage (33-122), Critical (30%), Social (20)
Very Slow 2-Hit
Battle Hammer
Alexina:
1. Idris - Damage (74-188), Critical (41%), Social (32)
2. Thing - Damage (60-148), Critical (38%), Social (24)
3. efansay - Damage (52-135), Critical (38%)
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi: Bizarrejuju - Damage (77-203), Critical (43%), Social (36)
Broad Axe
Alexina:
1. Thatha - Damage (96-207), Critical (32%)
2. Ekaterin - Damage (88-190), Critical (35%), Social (29)
3. Romanji - Damage (89-185), Critical (36%), Social (32)
Mari: Taliya - Damage (77-171), Critical (29%), Social (21)
Tarlach:
1. Bloodyirish - Damage (105-213), Critical (43%), Social (39)
2. Kantetsu - Damage (95-193), Critical (32%), Social (28)
Ruairi:
Very Slow 3-Hit
Wooden Club
Alexina:
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
[/SPOILER]
[Image: http://img855.imageshack.us/img855/244/bowt.png]
[SPOILER="Spoiler"]
Awards
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png](40-44 social)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png](45-49 social)
[Image: http://i40.tinypic.com/1zfttl5.png](50 social)
Fast 2-Hit
Wing Bow
Alexina:
1. Lyf - Damage (70-129), Critical (54%), Social (50)
[Image: http://i40.tinypic.com/1zfttl5.png]
2. RONINwolf - Damage (43-116), Critical (54%)
3. Jahrakal - Damage (49-94), Critical (47%), Social (34)
Mari:
1. Junewai - Damage (37-76), Critical (42%)
2. Glassie - Damage (43-75), Critical (40%)
3. hunterman - Damage (29-51), Critical (40%), Social (19)
Tarlach:
1. Azurai - Damage (67-123), Critical (52%), Social (47)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png]
2. xxrequiemxx - Damage (64-112), Critical (50%), Social (43)
3. Akama - Damage (57-110), Critical (47%), Social (38)
Ruairi: Ylpmis - Damage (68-121), Critical (53%), Social (45)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png]
Fast 3-Hit
Elven Short Bow
Alexina: Hijiri - Damage (44-96), Critical (42%), Social (30)
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
Normal 2-Hit
Ring Bow
Alexina:
1. Beanie - Damage (79-155), Critical (37%), Social ()
2. Aaron303 - Damage (72-145), Critical (31%)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
3. Forgotten - Damage (76-135), Critical (34%), Social (42)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
Mari:
1. Shisen - Damage (36-80), Critical (24%), Social (22)
2. Vanof - Damage (32-52), Critical (22%), Social (16)
Tarlach:
1. Lustday - Damage (62-114), Critical (29%), Social (34)
2. Guild - Damage (51-94), Critical (28%), Social (30)
3. Arisato - Damage (51-90), Critical (28%), Social (29)
Ruairi:
1. Jovo - Damage (87-155), Critical (37%), Social (50)
[Image: http://i40.tinypic.com/1zfttl5.png]
2. Blanks - Damage (87-155), Critical (37%), Social (50)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png]
3. Maia - Damage (79-155), Critical (37%), Social (47)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png]
Highlander Long Bow
Alexina:
1. seanyb - Damage (67-106), Critical (41%), Social (36)
2. Demonbiscuit - Damage (53-80), Critical (37%)
3. Sybill - Damage (44-61), Critical (33%), Social (21)
Mari:
Tarlach:
1. hylianblade - Damage (63-120), Critical (41%), Social (37)
Ruairi: Chro - Damage (46-61), Critical (35%), Social (21)
Normal 3-Hit
Crossbow
Alexina:
1. Arias - Damage (29-49), Critical (40%)
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
Arbalest
Alexina:
1. Kaeporo - Damage (65-120), Critical (67%), Social (46)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png]
2. Connan - Damage (31-46), Critical (50%)
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
Composite Bow
Alexina: Kaser - Damage (70-112), Critical (34%)
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi: Shizuhara - Damage (70-94), Critical (28%), Social (30)
Slow 3-Hit
Guardian Bow
Alexina:
1. Tsukitenebra - Damage (54-100), Critical (34%), Social (32)
2. Auburn - Damage (35-63), Critical (26%), Social (21)
Mari: Praedator - Damage (44-81), Critical (29%), Social (26)
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
Long Bow
Alexina:
Mari:
Tarlach: Hatsunechan - Damage (64-96), Critical (26%), Social (32)
Ruairi:
Leather Long Bow
Alexina:
1. Sylpi - Damage (77-125), Critical (48%), Social (46)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png]
2. Ravendor - Damage (77-122), Critical (46%), Social (45)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png]
3. xcrushx - Damage (73-117), Critical (45%), Social (41)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
Mari: Starmiyaka - Damage (77-122), Critical (46%), Social (48)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png]
Tarlach:
1. Rekhyt - Damage (75-115), Critical (43%), Social (41)
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png]
2. Rappard - Damage (70-112)
Ruairi: Asao - Damage (72-133), Critical (48%), Social (46)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png]
[/SPOILER]
[Image: http://img849.imageshack.us/img849/4535/wandv.png]
[SPOILER="Spoiler"]
Awards
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png](40-44 social)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png](45-49 social)
[Image: http://i40.tinypic.com/1zfttl5.png](50 social)
Ice Wand
Alexina: Zeo - Damage (27-45), Critical (23%), Social (26)
Mari: Panda - Damage (41-63), Critical (24%), Social (32)
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
Crown Ice Wand
Alexina: Azareel - Consumption (-4%), Speed (+2%), Damage (+8%), Critical Damage (+3%), Social (23)
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
Fire Wand
Alexina:
Mari:
1. Rayoks - Damage (47-93), Critical (21%), Social (35)
2. Inabi - Damage (36-68), Critical (21%)
3. Habistus - Damage (24-44), Critical (17%)
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
Phoenix Fire Wand
Alexina:
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi: Araria - Consumption (-3%), Speed (+8%), Damage (+4%), Critical Damage (+3%), Social (18)
Lightning Wand
Alexina:
1. Aahzmandius - Damage (30-80), Critical (12%)
2. Tenko - Damage (36-87), Critical (12%), Social (31)
3. Paraskevi - Damage (23-61), Critical (11%), Social (22)
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
Crystal Lightning wand
Alexina: link911 - Consumption (-6%), Speed (+2%), Damage (+4%), Critical Damage (+4%), Social (21)
Mari:
Tarlach: Johny - Consumption (-9%), Speed (+4%), Damage (+5%), Critical Damage (+4%), Social (28)
Ruairi:
Tikka Wood Healing Wand
Alexina:
Mari: Teraschione - Damage (35-63), Critical (24%), Social (31)
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
Combat Wand
Alexina: DAEMANO - Damage (40-64), Critical (28%), Social (21)
Mari:
Tarlach: Barding - Damage (27-44), Critical (25%), Social (20)
Ruairi: Yukistar - Damage (59-100), Critical (34%), Social (33)
[/SPOILER]
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/295u3xk.png]
[SPOILER="Spoiler"]
Awards
[Image: http://i43.tinypic.com/20ptwf8.png](40-44 social)
[Image: http://i42.tinypic.com/1z1h1rn.png](45-49 social)
[Image: http://i40.tinypic.com/1zfttl5.png](50 social)
Cylinder
Alexina: Edeott - Damage (1-9), Critical (5%), Social (23)
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi: Hwan - Damage (1-9), Critical (5%), Social (30)
Fire Cylinder
Alexina:
Mari:
Tarlach: Drawing - Fire (+69%), Water (+20%), Clay (+21%), Wind (+5%), Social (37)
Ruairi:
Tidal Wave Cylinder
Alexina: Tropacat - Fire (+23%), Water (+14%), Clay (+10%), Wind (+3%), Social (21)
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
Volcano Cylinder
Alexina: Pureblood - Fire (+8%), Water (+3%), Clay (+3%), Wind (+0%), Social (7)
Mari:
Tarlach:
1. Animist - Fire (+78%), Water (+20%), Clay (+30%), Wind (+5%), Social (36)
2. Kostacious - Damage (3-12), Critical (5%), Social (21)
Ruairi:
Earthquake Cylinder
Alexina: Wailyn - Fire (+25%), Water (+8%), Clay (+1%), Wind (+6%)
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi:
Tower Cylinder
Alexina:
Mari:
Tarlach:
Ruairi: Boners - Damage (1-9), Critical (5%)
[/SPOILER]
The list will be narrowed down until we have the strongest weapon(s) in each server. Feel free to post your own spirit weapon until we reach that phase.
A Note on Reputation
If you're looking at gaining some "rep" contributions to this thread which are accurate and follow the posted format will receive "rep" if possible. I have a decent reputation so you should get a nice bonus for each post.
That format seriously saves me a bunch of time.
Format:
[SPOILER="Spoiler"]
Swords/Blunts/Bows/Wands
Format:
[SIZE="1"]Server: Username - Damage (x-x), Critical (x%), Social (x); Weapon[/SIZE]
Example:
[SIZE="1"]Alexina: Kaeporo - Damage (65-120), Critical (67%), Social (46); Arbalest[/SIZE]
Advanced Wands
Format:
[SIZE="1"]Server: Username - Consumption (-x%), Speed (+x%), Damage (+x%), Critical Damage (+x%), Social (x); Wand[/SIZE]
Example:
[SIZE="1"]Alexina: link911 - Consumption (-6%), Speed (+2%), Damage (+4%), Critical Damage (+4%), Social (21); Crystal Lightning Wand[/SIZE]
Cylinders
Format:
[SIZE="1"]Server: Username - Fire (+x%), Water (+x%), Clay (+x%), Wind (+x%), Social (x); Cylinder[/SIZE]
Example:
[SIZE="1"]Tarlach: Animist - Fire (+78%), Water (+20%), Clay (+30%), Wind (+5%), Social (36); Volcano Cylinder[/SIZE]
Notice: Weapons will be judged on the following statistics when tied with another weapon:
1. Social level
2. Maximum Damage
3. Critical
4. Minimum Damage
[/SPOILER]
I want to thank everyone who has made contributions to this thread. It sure has come a long way.