MabiBeats.com - New MML Music Site [NA] - Page 2 | Life Skills Discussion

This is an archive of the mabination.com forums which were active from 2010 to 2018. You can not register, post or otherwise interact with the site other than browsing the content for historical purposes. The content is provided as-is, from the moment of the last backup taken of the database in 2019. Image and video embeds are disabled on purpose and represented textually since most of those links are dead.

To view other archive projects go to https://archives.mabination.com

MabiBeats.com - New MML Music Site [NA]

delight wrote on 2015-09-23 11:55
So my claims are
- 1. You used a portion of my previous (outdated too) works and labeled them as your works, a.k.a, MabiBeats Version, without any credits given.
- 2. The previous MabiMML.co version you put on your previous site was a direct rename from my modified version, without any credits given.
- 3. I registered as delight and posted in MabiMML.co regarding this issue, but received no response. Now you claim you do not know me, but continue to steal part of my works.
- 4. On your site, I have also found MMLs copied from other sites (e.g., official MabiMML, Code House, YYDZH, MabinogiFWS, etc.), without credits provided. Some of them are modified, but they are worse than the original versions.
If you want to build MabiBeats version, please start from scratch by downloading the official version and work from there, instead of stealing others' work and provide no credit, with the excuse of "I do not know the source".
Rydian wrote on 2015-09-23 13:40

Er, for 4, given that it's a user-submission thing, isn't that not him doing it?
delight wrote on 2015-09-23 13:53

Of course, but I do not see a field to fill in original author or source, neither this is not a requirement for his site.
Yasuno wrote on 2015-09-23 16:29
Quote from delight;1287227:
So my claims are
- 1. You used a portion of my previous (outdated too) works and labeled them as your works, a.k.a, MabiBeats Version, without any credits given.
- 2. The previous MabiMML.co version you put on your previous site was a direct rename from my modified version, without any credits given.
- 3. I registered as delight and posted in MabiMML.co regarding this issue, but received no response. Now you claim you do not know me, but continue to steal part of my works.
- 4. On your site, I have also found MMLs copied from other sites (e.g., official MabiMML, Code House, YYDZH, MabinogiFWS, etc.), without credits provided. Some of them are modified, but they are worse than the original versions.
If you want to build MabiBeats version, please start from scratch by downloading the official version and work from there, instead of stealing others' work and provide no credit, with the excuse of "I do not know the source".
It's official, you are quite crazy. :whistle:
1. Again, I had no clue you had any "works" in this 3MLE, we have been over this.. i don't know who you are no matter what you claim.
2. Didn't know about that either.
3. Still, i do not remember nor know who you are. Even if you did register, that does not change the fact that i have no clue who you are, Each site version always reaches well over 1,000 registered members so you can't expect me to know each one. And nor do i have any way of knowing what is really "your works"
4. We do not control the users, they submit anything they want. 9 Staff members handle approval of submissions, users could put down any credits, including the wrong credits and all 9 of us would not know if they are telling the truth or not. We only moderate by keeping out spam, and broken song code.

As an aside, since you seem to be on a "justice" spree go attack the other sites as well who do not have credit fields then come back and let me know how it goes. I will mention though, on our site a lot of users post the credits in the author comment section at the bottom of the MML Posting. But, it is up to them we are not going to micromanage thousands of submissions and force them to, you are being silly if you expect that. This is all volunteer work we are doing, this is not our job.

Quote from Rydian;1287231:
Er, for 4, given that it's a user-submission thing, isn't that not him doing it?

This guy is off his knocker Rydian, as you can see im explaining in a clear and concise manner and he keeps going in circles instead.

Quote from delight;1287235:
Of course, but I do not see a field to fill in original author or source, neither this is not a requirement for his site.

Originally, on V3 of the site we had that field. No one used it, some did but very, very few. And making the field a requirement would literally do nothing they will just type in "wouihfworhfgowhiug" and then hit submit. We have no way to check either if the credits are really valid, and we are not going to deny every submission that does not have proper credits considering some of these songs might even be from 2007 and there is no way to know who the author is anyways.

Your high and mighty attitude is really off-putting, and if you are so upset please go make your own site, with your own set of all volunteers, and then put in all these very strict requirements you seem to want and let me know how it goes for ya.

--Im going to request topic closure, whether they close it or not it doesn't matter but i am done giving you the decency of replying you are absolutely a ridiculous person.