Whistling Stone Fragments

• Dage47 wrote on 2015-08-02 00:35
  Hi there, I've been snooping on the forums and other sites (google, mabinogi Wiki, and such) And I seen there wasn't an actual guide on "Find the Whistling Rock 'A-G' " Of course to some people, it might be common sense, but I've asked around in my friends list and no one seems to know how to Harmonize with the whistling rock. I found somewhere saying I needed a scroll with "t200L64a", without the quotes of course. As for even finding the whistling rock, I've went by the picture given in the "Creating Harmonies with empty bottles" quest guide. I'm not sure if it matters if they're Tonic, Dominant, or Subdominant
  
  http://wiki.mabinogiworld.com/images/e/e8/TranslatedMap.png
  
  So my questions are, Is there a way to find the correct stone in a correct location, and How to harmonize it according to the quest. I understand that you do not need every bottle for each Fragment. I have "A,D,E, and F"
  
  

  If I've over looked somewhere on a guide on this, I'm very sorry.
  :bow:
• Citrusjuice wrote on 2015-08-02 01:36
  i recently did this quest with bottles F A G and D.
  One method to do it is find a whisting rock via L-rod and use playing instrument facing the rock with all bottles and see if you get it. You get the requirement immediately if it is the correct bottle/stone. If not just try other bottles and repeat. You should be done in like idk half an hour if you're lucky lmao...
  
  Alternative option is to ask a modder to assist you. They usually have the map with markings.
• callback wrote on 2015-08-02 01:39
  (copied from wiki)
  

  [Image: http://wiki.mabinogiworld.com/images/e/e8/TranslatedMap.png]

  
  Tonic: Notes C, E, G
  Dominant: B, G, D
  Subdominant: F, A, C
  
  
  You only need one bottle from each set. Otherwise just follow the map and find where to use it.
• Dage47 wrote on 2015-08-02 03:27
  @Citrusjuice- I'm going to try that thank you, but this requirement, is it to the quest "Finding the Whistling Rock 'A-G'"? It says to find the stone first, but I'm pretty sure by now I've uncovered the stone multiple of times.
  
  @callback- I have the map, but thank you for showing me, I only mentioned it because, I thought if the stones had a scale it would only be usable for the quest "Creating Harmonies with Empty Bottles"
  
  So Now I know that playing instrument is the way to harmonize, now all I need to confirm is that can I use the same stones used in "Creating harmonies" for "Finding the Whistling stone". I'm searching now as I type, No luck so far..
  
  

  Thank you for the quick responses btw.
  :2thumb:
• Darkboy132 wrote on 2015-08-02 04:27
  Have you tried playing all your bottles in every marked area? It has to be playing instrument only.
• Dage47 wrote on 2015-08-02 19:09
  @Darkboy- I'll try that today and post any result tomorrow, and I wont use a score scroll this time, though now I have to hope for the stones to appear longer then 20 seconds, to try all the bottles.
  
  By the way is there a reason the stones aren't displaying if it's a "Whistling stone D" and such?
• Citrusjuice wrote on 2015-08-02 19:29

  Quote from Dage47;1283277:

  @Darkboy- I'll try that today and post any result tomorrow, and I wont use a score scroll this time, though now I have to hope for the stones to appear longer then 20 seconds, to try all the bottles.
  
  By the way is there a reason the stones aren't displaying if it's a "Whistling stone D" and such?

  
  
  because devcat hates you.
  
  Note that the moment playing instrument activates the requirement should be filled if the correct bottle is played.
  
  U can also try matching the map shown in wiki and cc to each channel on that specific spot so you know you need to play bottle for example A
• Dage47 wrote on 2015-08-03 21:51
  Update: The First Objective doesn't even Complete it self when I discover any of the 'D' Whistling stones on the map Callback gave."
  
  http://grab.by/JjZ4