Quote from December;1292328:
I actually like playing the new poppy, albeit I never played the old one.
I know anecdotal evidence doesn't mean much against statistics, but I feel she does good damage despite being able to build quite tanky.
Her skills feel rewarding to use, especially W which can prevent engages and escapes such as Lucian dashes away or thresh lanterns. Her Q is hard to land, but does 6% heath max.
My build for top is:
0/18/9 with Ignite
First item Corrupting Potion > Trinity force > Tank items
AD Quints/Marks, Flat AR Seals, Scaling MR Glpyhs
First point Q then E or W depending on whether they use dashes (W is so great against riven)
I've also done poppy jungle and support
But that's the thing, for what poppy actually brings to the table, you could play renekton or mundo and get nearly the same thing done better toplane, in jungle she doesn't really bring anything amazing either save for a wallpin, as a support she stops a dash and can remove someone from a fight once every few minutes. She gets stupidly beefy and her ult is kinda annoying, but she really doesn't bring much to the table outside of a wall slam and 1 jump cockblock.
Her kit isn't good enough right now, I'm sure with a few small tweaks here or mini buffs there she'd be phenomenal, but she doesn't do anything that well, or have her own expertise where she shines
As a support/carry babysitter she has some decent tools, but others can do it better still lol, same with her jungle or toplane, too many others just simply do what she does better. She doesn't shine anywhere, outside of the ult taking someone from a fight for 3-4 seconds, but lolotherultsdoitbetter
Take what i say with a grain of salt, but I've played toplane poppy enough with the old poppy this new one just feels so bad to use, and that's saying something. Most wont feel the same as me, but that's because most didn't dedicate 2 years of their gameplay to poppy alone.
Poppy used to be the ultimate iron asshole test, can you lane and make it to 20 minutes without getting destroyed? If so please enjoy the next 20 minutes of anticarry goodness that is completely unparalleled. Now she's just another beefy champion with some random stuff in her kit that seems like 'fun'.