What state did this happen in?
Texas
What state did this happen in?
Texas
It was meant to convey a point, not entertain you. However, since it seems I need to be more legalistic in my speech, let me try again.
What you can type up while sitting calmly at your desk does not take into account a myriad of factors present in the actual situation. You're absolutely, without question, incorrect.
As it stands, jail time is almost completely ineffective in stemming pedophilia. To suggest a stern talking to will suffice isn't even funny. Furthermore, sexual abuse by a stranger is always traumatic. The only dispute is whether the trauma is permanent. Having one's father come to the rescue, with this level of violence, is not traumatic. Her mind isn't on 'oh god the violence' but on whether her perceived attacker is no longer a threat.
Note, I'm not trying to justify what he did...just pointing out the seemingly obvious flaws in your cardboard stiff assessment.
http://mabination.com/threads/55302-SK%E2%80%99s-First-Chemical-Castration-of-a-Pedophile
All of the evidence on the table (witnesses, police reports, etc.) paint a very clear picture. A man molests a 4-year old girl and is confronted by her father. There is a fight, though it's unclear if it was one-sided, and the molester dies. We don't know if the father intended to kill him or not or if it was unavoidable. We're certainly not just taking his word for it.
What people in the thread are saying is that they would do the same thing. This may not be perfect, but it's honest. Also, how would you prefer your murders to be done? Since fists are too barbaric, what's an appropriate method for 2012?
I can agree that murder is never the right answer, but let's be honest, we don't know what happened yet.
My bad. I didn't realize he only touches little girls to impregnate them. Taking away his sperm factories will solve eeeeeeverything.
Reduces his testosterone so he doesn't wanna do that all the time.
People should be able to control themselves.
He could have been doing what all of you are suggesting and beating the crap out of it and took it too far.
rape tends to be more of a control thing, which is mental not physical.
Don't feel like having sex, why rape.
If you have no libido takes the point away from rape.
Okay and then they'll find other ways to find the power they desire, like kidnapping or killing.
If that's the problem then other punishment is due?????
If that's the problem then other punishment is due?????
Why give them that opportunity?
I think all rapists should be in jail, and when their sentence is up they have to attend therapy and should be under total house arrest for the rest of their lives.