Mabinogi KR Suggestion of the Month No.1 (September Edition)

• ＣＩＲＮＯ wrote on 2013-10-01 21:09

  Quote from Kenero;1154722:

  Somebody once suggested there should be healing Mastery which increases, not only healing amount, but how much percent of wounds you heal, with rank 1 healing 80% of your healing spells cures wounds and with r1, finest bandage can heal 60% of your HP bar at once of wounds.

  
  
  However, this isn't adding new skills in or what-so-ever...
  
  It's to fix an old, somewhat broken, one to match up with the stats that we are supposed to see.
  
  Unless, of course, there are some hidden formulas in which:
  
  #1 - My healing reforges isn't working or it isn't even adding that 25 HP/ Healing reforges now doesn't stack
  
  or
  
  #2 - My heal is acting extremely weird.
  
  In which, both ways are pretty negative :v
• Kurayami wrote on 2013-10-01 21:25

  Quote from Osu;1154712:

  -snip-

  
  It sucks how I cant post anywhere without almost always getting a [S]smart ass[/S] negative remark from that person.
  
  What a warrior lacks is skills that can deal massive damage
  You see dropkick has 800% damage,
  flash launcher at 800%
  etc
  
  While smash 500% (600 Giant) and windmill at 250%
  Smash, normal attack, windmill that's pretty much all a warrior can do at the moment to deal good damage. Without a lance and reforges up your ass you wont get anywhere close to the damage other skillsets can deal.
  
  The lack of skills to use makes the talent very dull.
  
  There are obviously numerous skills that one could come up with, for example let me pull something off the top of my head.
  Let's use a skill that is similar to fighter's focused fist. Let's call it Slash for lack of a better name.
  You would charge up an attack that the longer you hold it the higher the damage and range it has, but with a cone shaped area of effect instead of the single target one focused fist has.
  Releasing that lets out a sharp horizontal slash dealing damage to all the enemies inside of the area. This could be sword exclusive as well since lances cant exactly slash.
  
  Basically what warriors need are Active Skills and buffs to the non-lance weapon types. It doesn't even matter which skills, just any at all would be nice to mix up the dull play style of warriors.
• RMorichika wrote on 2013-10-01 21:29
  I would like to formally request a new item called glue. When used, it applies itself to your shoulders to ensure that your arms remain attached at all times. I think it's necessary because, at some point, my arms have picked up the habit of floating three feet (in-game distance) away from my body, in a seeming attempt to emulate the popular video game character Rayman. While I do like Rayman, I would prefer it if my arms remained firmly attached to my body.
• Slayerj wrote on 2013-10-01 21:41

  Quote from Kenero;1154696:

  Wouldn't hurt to add more details. =)

  
  
  Oh god. I'll talk the ideas over with my friends for more details and resubmit it. Hope I get that done in time, got a HIS essay to complete today XD;...
• Osu wrote on 2013-10-01 21:41

  Quote from Kurayami;1154726:

  *a fellow snip*

  
  
  I guess just try and brush it off nwn;
  
  But~ I do think smash having its percentage lower is still just fine since most weapons have way less max to factor in due to a lack of dual wielding.. [s]though that lower percentage indeed does suck for elves, but hey this is a melee discussion anyway~[/s]
  
  And your slash idea is similar to something I thought about for two handed weapons. xP A charging type of move where you simply raise your blade into the air(or blunt end for giants with two handed blunts) and let it build up until you crash it down into the ground for massive damage. :U Since it would exceed smash and all, perhaps throw in a small moment of immobility after the blow?
  But the fact remains that just about anything in terms of more skills would be an improvement. I'm not gonna lie though, if they did that for us, I think lances could use it too('cause let's face it, that's a really small ass talent xD), but I think other melee weapons should get the bulk of the improvement so things even out.
  
  

  Quote from RMorichika;1154729:

  I would like to formally request a new item called glue. When used, it applies itself to your shoulders to ensure that your arms remain attached at all times. I think it's necessary because, at some point, my arms have picked up the habit of floating three feet (in-game distance) away from my body, in a seeming attempt to emulate the popular video game character Rayman. While I do like Rayman, I would prefer it if my arms remained firmly attached to my body.

  
  *hugs* Thank you for that. xD
• Syr wrote on 2013-10-01 21:45

  Quote from Goldenchikle;1154611:

  -- Buff tower cylinders; give them a mastery, allow them to make use of elemental wave and golden time, and allow golem AI to be used with them. Also decrease the install time (or make that a perk of the mastery skill). With the addition of guard cylinders and Vates alchemy skills they're falling behind. I'd like to see them become relevant again.

  
  
  You forgot about letting them be special upgradeable.
  
  In fact, why not let all weapons be special upgradeable? Scythes just became special upgradeable, why not let the ones that can be upgraded + gem upgrade be spec upp'd?
• Cyrene wrote on 2013-10-01 22:17
  Revamp dungeon level design. Add an actual assortment of caverns instead of just rooms with monster spawn button in the center how about making actual traps and trip wires. Like this can be added by having trapdoors and if you step on one you fall into a room with a random boss monster like for example a adv ciar golem and if you kill it without dying you get a free extra end chest at the end of the dungeon with boosted reward and droprate. Replace the long boring copy paste rooms with caverns kinda like ant hell add traps at the end of halways like panels that shoot poison arrows or something. Make alby look darker with giant webs and stalactites and stalagmites and stuff in the dungeouns and make exploring the dungeoun more confusing and dangeroous and actually tough. but make the rewards actually good instead of 1 demonic ore.
  Someone help me expand on this idea I got nothing.
  
  Increase drop rates of dungeoun passes to like 30 percent drop rate.
  
  Make craftable theatre missions selectable instead of random.
  Someone expand on this idea
• Takuji wrote on 2013-10-01 22:31
  Mob A.I Revamp
  
  Currently Mobs are for the most part predictable, easy to counter, and in parties of competence and efficiency post no challenges. After a player gets over the learning curve and memorizes each A.I category for them they no longer provide any unpredictability or challenge.
  
  What should be implemented is multiple A.I's and mobs spawn with a random A.I from a list of available A.I's. The number and type of A.I should be appropriate to the difficulty of the dungeon/shadow mission. The A.I's should also react dramatically to certain player-used skills. For example if a player attacks a mob using a fighter-skill the mob should react by triggering multi-aggro or double aggro on the player to provide a challenge to a 1v1 skillset. If the mob is hit by an A.I resetting skill such as Windmill, the A.I should either change to another random A.I or not change at all and be immune to such A.I altering skills. Mobs should also be given limited aoe mob-only (Like stomp use to be) skills to better handle a party and only use them in rooms with certain amounts of players. Along with mob-only aoe skills, certain mini-boss or boss mobs should have a final desperation type skill to potentially OHKO a party
  
  A radical idea I want to propose as well is buffing up all mobs to the dynamic combat system the players use. With the recent defense buff, it won't matter what stat modifications the mobs receive if they can't keep up with the players. It needs to be even ground again. Players now should be well equipped to handle rapid multi-aggro and should be challenged by thinking quick and fast like the fighting system they are currently using.
  
  This would be a good addition to mabinogi because players who have invested money, time, and effort into their characters should be challenged to the degree of preparation available to them. Mobs do not need to do more damage or have more hp or defense to last longer they need to become a threat to the player and be able to defeat them from time to time. This will encourage a desire in the player to adjust their equipment accordingly, defeat the mob, and feel their preparations were worth it in the long run, not empty now that is too easy.
  
  Permanent Lorraine's Nightmare
  
  The concept of "Lorraine's Nightmare" should be implemented as content in the game. Completing a wave by wave survival type mission with more gold and better prizes the more rounds you complete. It would provide more variety to players rather than continuously playing the same shadow mission and the one worth while theater mission (MA) as well as give new players a feel for other skillsets with out having wasted AP when they may later not enjoy the playstyle as much as they thought.
  
  (I'll expand in detail later exactly what should be put in this or if anyone else likes this event and has ideas please quote and share)
  
  Separation of eye and head wear
  
  I'm not sure if this needs much detail it's fairly straight forward
  
  Eyewear like shades, glasses, eyepatches should be separate from regular head wear just to provide more aesthetic choice in how a player wants their character to look. It would make some fashinogi's happy and they can simply be an aesthetic piece like robes (can't be enchanted, upgraded, reforged, provides no defense or protection)
• Cyrene wrote on 2013-10-01 22:45

  Quote from Takuji;1154751:

  Mob A.I Revamp
  stuff

  
  
  If I recall they were going to give monsters dynamic combat originally but then it would just become a guessing game and would be horrible for players with latency issues. Also a part of dynamic combat was removing stun effects on player characters. Bringing that back could add challenge actual challenge instead of a one hit kill attacks that mmo developers add to be lazy. Though to add better Ai just give all monsters martial arts enemy AI. It works well and monsters actually try to combo and heal each other.
  
  Also I'd like to add monsters didn't really get a buff from the stat changes. Only players really got that op defense where taking 1s in sms is now simple that a newbie giant could do it in a couple of rbs.
• Carlonia wrote on 2013-10-01 23:36
  I saw Melee Hero and my mind went 'OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH',
  
  So here's what I came up with in ~20 minutes...
  
  [SPOILER=Information]
  Samurai Hero Talent:-
  
  Close Combat, Archery, Fighter
  
  Remove % chance for Defense/Protection debuff. Bone Dragon is already 100%.
  Nerf Sword Mastery to 50% of it's current effects. Effects activate whenever using any type of sword, and stack with Two-Handed, One-Handed Sword and Dual-Wield Masteries.
  Elves can now use Two-Handed weapons (excluding Lances).
  
  New skills for Swords/Spears:
  -Weak Spot
  Reduces Def/Prot of enemy (much like Spinning Uppercut).
  Stacks with Spinning Uppercut and Dragon Dash.
  Ignores Protection for critical chance.
  Faster animation than Smash, doesn't provide knockback, stuns same as a regular hit with the equipped weapon
  For Dual Wield, +50% damage on One-Handed damage % (occurs at the end of damage calculation).
  Obtained via: Rebirth with Zero Card/Create with Hero/Elite Hero card OR
  Obtain Rank 1 in Sword Mastery, Two-Handed Mastery, Single-Handed Sword Mastery, Dual-Wield Mastery
  
  

  [Image: http://img18.imageshack.us/img18/3514/m2j4.png]

  
  
  
  
  -Fury
  Two-Handed only
  Four successive hits, resulting in prolonged stun (1-5 seconds added to regular weapon stun)
  Ignores Protection for critical chance.
  Can be hit during animation, skill will stop and enemy will not be stunned at all.
  Obtained via: Rebirth with Zero Card/Create with Hero/Elite Hero card OR
  Obtain Rank 1 in Sword Mastery, Two-Handed Sword Mastery.
  
  

  [Image: http://img593.imageshack.us/img593/4912/4mwl.png]

  
  
  
  -Two-Handed Mastery
  Obtained via: Equip any Two-Handed weapon.
  Passively increases Damage and Critical % when equipped with a Two-Handed weapon. Higher ranks provide greater effects.
  
  

  [Image: http://img21.imageshack.us/img21/5766/qgpj.png]

  
  
  
  -One Handed Sword Mastery
  Obtained via: Equip any One-Handed Sword.
  Passively increases Damage and Injury % when equipped with One-Handed swords.
  
  

  [Image: http://img854.imageshack.us/img854/4146/cu6h.png]

  
  
  
  -Dual Wield Mastery
  Obtained via: Dual-wield any sword.
  Passively increases Damage when dual-wielding swords.
  Effects overwrite the effects of One-Handed Sword Mastery.
  
  

  [Image: http://img208.imageshack.us/img208/3431/pp82.png]

  
  
  
  
  New Weapons:-
  
  Spear-type:
  No minimum distance. Maximum distance: 75
  Craftable with Blacksmithing/purchased from Edern.
  Follows Two-Handed Sword upgrades, minus any that include "Two-Handed Sword" in their name, and Artisan.
  
  -Short Spear
  Damage: 30-50 (Maximum 96 after upgrades)
  Injury: 5-10%
  Balance: 50%
  Critical: 20% (Maximum 36% after upgrades)
  Durability: 12
  Stun: 2 Seconds (Normal, 3-hit weapon)
  Stamina Cost per swing: 1.5
  Purchase Price: 25,000 Gold
  
  Crafting information:
  Manual Rank: 5
  Materials: Iron Ingot x2, Mythril Ingot x4
  25% Average Complete per success
  Finishing Materials: 2 Fine Leather Straps, 2 Braids
  Manual Location: Barri Edern's Secret Pass
  
  Unique Upgrades:
  
  Hardened Tip
  Max Damage +15, Minimum Damage +5
  Durability -5
  Upgrade: 3-3
  Proficiency: 75, Gold: 15,000
  NPC: Edern
  
  Extend Pole
  Maximum Distance +75
  Durability -3
  Upgrade 4-4
  Proficiency: 100, Gold: 25,000
  NPC: Edern
  
  Artisan:
  Strength +10~60
  Dexterity -0~20
  Luck +20~50
  Proficiency: 100, Gold: 40,000
  NPC: Edern
  
  
  -Halberd
  Damage: 20-60 (Maximum 117 after Upgrades)
  Injury: 0-5%
  Balance: 20%
  Critical: 10% (Maximum 26% after Upgrades)
  Stun: 2.8 Seconds (Slow, 2-hit weapon)
  Durability: 15
  Stamina Cost per swing: 2.5
  Purchase Price: 30,000 Gold
  
  Crafting Information:
  Manual Rank: 2
  Materials: Iron Ingot x3, Mythril Ingot x4, Gold Ingot x2
  15% Average Complete per success
  Finishing Materials: 4 Fine Leather Straps, 3 Tough Strings
  Manual Location: Barri Edern's Secret Pass
  
  Unique Upgrades:
  
  Sharpen Edges
  Upgrade 3-3
  Maximum Damage +20
  Minimum Damage +10
  Durability -5
  Critical +10%
  Proficiency: 60, Gold: 15,000
  NPC: Edern
  
  Add Weight
  Upgrade 4-4
  Maximum Damage +20
  Minimum Damage -15
  Balance -20%
  Proficiency: 85, Gold: 30,000
  
  Artisan
  Strength +0~75
  Dexterity -20~50
  Luck -0~25
  HP +5~10
  Proficiency: 100, Gold: 50,000
  NPC: Edern
  
  
  New Dungeon:-
  Barri Edern's Secret
  Obtained via: 'Elen the Fool' Questline
  Quest #1 'Super Secret Stuff'
  [SPOILER=Quest]Quest Details:
  'Hey, so Grandpa keeps disappearing into Barri recently, and he's been making some things that he's not teaching me about. I wanna know what's going on!'
  -Elen
  
  Objectives:
  1. Talk to Elen.
  2. Purchase a [Short Spear] from Edern and take it to Elen.
  3. Purchase a [Halberd] from Edern and take it to Elen.
  4. Use 'Elen's Prototype' Manual to create an item. (Which would be 'Dull Spear', not-equippable)
  5. Take the Dull Spear to Edern.
  
  Rewards: 25,000 Exp
  [/SPOILER]
  
  Quest #2 'Foolish Girl'
  [SPOILER=Quest]Quest Details:
  'So Elen figured out what I was doing, eh? I guess it's time to come clean..'
  -Edern
  
  Objectives:
  1: Talk to Edern.
  2: Bring Edern 5 Mythril Ingots.
  
  Rewards: Barri 'Edern's Secret' Pass, Keyword 'Edern's Secret Pass', 50,000 Exp, 25,000 Gold
  [/SPOILER]
  Use Keyword with Edern for more passes at 5,000 Gold each.
  [/SPOILER]
  
  There's room for improvement, but I'll stop before I really do something wrong. Feel free to add/criticise/remove~
  
  Shit, forgot about that dungeon pass.. gimme 10 minutes to think up a quest to get the pass... (DONE.)
  Forgot something else, you know, WHAT'S ACTUALLY IN THE DUNGEON. 10 more minutes...
  
  [SPOILER=Dungeon]
  Barri 'Edern's Secret' Dungeon:-
  
  Contains spawns from Barri Advanced, and Golems from The Other Alchemists Hard (Stone and Forest).
  
  Spawn Patterns include regular Barri Advanced patterns, plus some spawns of 2-5 Golems.
  
  Boss Room:
  Snow Golem x3 (TOA Elite standard with 2000 more HP, Regular Golem sized)
  Magic Golem (3x stats on Snow Golem, regular golem sized, Tabhartas movement speed and wound rate)
  
  Rewards:
  (Common)
  10,000-15,000 Gold
  Mythril Ingot x5
  Mana Herb
  Short Spear (Base Grade)
  Halberd (Base Grade)
  
  (Rare)
  Blacksmith Manual - Short Spear
  Blacksmith Manual - Halberd
  [/SPOILER]
  
  Hope I haven't missed something else, though I probably have.
• Natural Harmonia Gropius wrote on 2013-10-01 23:49
  1) Scrap the piece of shit game engine it has now and rework the game from the ground up to be something worthwhile
  2) Rework dungeons to work similarly to shadow missions, at the very least in method of entry. Increase rewards to make running them worthwhile, be it end reward and possibly monster drops.
  3) Remodel and re-texture some of the old, incredibly shitty hair selections. Doesn't have to be the free hair selections, but some of the premium ones look fucking terrible.
  4) Move away from Solonogi content. Do something to promote the MULTIPLAYER part of MMORPG, which Mabinogi is supposed to be. If I wanted to be a recluse I would play a single player game that would end up being 50x better than Mabi simply because it isn't Mabi.
• Carlonia wrote on 2013-10-02 00:07

  Quote from Carlonia;1154767:

  I saw Melee Hero and my mind went 'OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH',
  
  So here's what I came up with in ~20 minutes...
  
  [SPOILER=Information]
  Samurai Hero Talent:-
  
  Close Combat, Archery, Fighter
  
  Remove % chance for Defense/Protection debuff. Bone Dragon is already 100%.
  Nerf Sword Mastery to 50% of it's current effects. Effects activate whenever using any type of sword, and stack with Two-Handed, One-Handed Sword and Dual-Wield Masteries.
  Elves can now use Two-Handed weapons (excluding Lances).
  
  New skills for Swords/Spears:
  -Weak Spot
  Reduces Def/Prot of enemy (much like Spinning Uppercut).
  Stacks with Spinning Uppercut and Dragon Dash.
  Ignores Protection for critical chance.
  Faster animation than Smash, doesn't provide knockback, stuns same as a regular hit with the equipped weapon
  For Dual Wield, +50% damage on One-Handed damage % (occurs at the end of damage calculation).
  Obtained via: Rebirth with Zero Card/Create with Hero/Elite Hero card OR
  Obtain Rank 1 in Sword Mastery, Two-Handed Mastery, Single-Handed Sword Mastery, Dual-Wield Mastery
  
  

  [Image: http://img18.imageshack.us/img18/3514/m2j4.png]

  
  
  
  
  -Fury
  Two-Handed only
  Four successive hits, resulting in prolonged stun (1-5 seconds added to regular weapon stun)
  Ignores Protection for critical chance.
  Can be hit during animation, skill will stop and enemy will not be stunned at all.
  Obtained via: Rebirth with Zero Card/Create with Hero/Elite Hero card OR
  Obtain Rank 1 in Sword Mastery, Two-Handed Sword Mastery.
  
  

  [Image: http://img593.imageshack.us/img593/4912/4mwl.png]

  
  
  
  -Two-Handed Mastery
  Obtained via: Equip any Two-Handed weapon.
  Passively increases Damage and Critical % when equipped with a Two-Handed weapon. Higher ranks provide greater effects.
  
  

  [Image: http://img21.imageshack.us/img21/5766/qgpj.png]

  
  
  
  -One Handed Sword Mastery
  Obtained via: Equip any One-Handed Sword.
  Passively increases Damage and Injury % when equipped with One-Handed swords.
  
  

  [Image: http://img854.imageshack.us/img854/4146/cu6h.png]

  
  
  
  -Dual Wield Mastery
  Obtained via: Dual-wield any sword.
  Passively increases Damage when dual-wielding swords.
  Effects overwrite the effects of One-Handed Sword Mastery.
  
  

  [Image: http://img208.imageshack.us/img208/3431/pp82.png]

  
  
  
  
  New Weapons:-
  
  Spear-type:
  No minimum distance. Maximum distance: 75
  Craftable with Blacksmithing/purchased from Edern.
  Follows Two-Handed Sword upgrades, minus any that include "Two-Handed Sword" in their name, and Artisan.
  
  -Short Spear
  Damage: 30-50 (Maximum 96 after upgrades)
  Injury: 5-10%
  Balance: 50%
  Critical: 20% (Maximum 36% after upgrades)
  Durability: 12
  Stun: 2 Seconds (Normal, 3-hit weapon)
  Stamina Cost per swing: 1.5
  Purchase Price: 25,000 Gold
  
  Crafting information:
  Manual Rank: 5
  Materials: Iron Ingot x2, Mythril Ingot x4
  25% Average Complete per success
  Finishing Materials: 2 Fine Leather Straps, 2 Braids
  Manual Location: Barri Edern's Secret Pass
  
  Unique Upgrades:
  
  Hardened Tip
  Max Damage +15, Minimum Damage +5
  Durability -5
  Upgrade: 3-3
  Proficiency: 75, Gold: 15,000
  NPC: Edern
  
  Extend Pole
  Maximum Distance +75
  Durability -3
  Upgrade 4-4
  Proficiency: 100, Gold: 25,000
  NPC: Edern
  
  Artisan:
  Strength +10~60
  Dexterity -0~20
  Luck +20~50
  Proficiency: 100, Gold: 40,000
  NPC: Edern
  
  
  -Halberd
  Damage: 20-60 (Maximum 117 after Upgrades)
  Injury: 0-5%
  Balance: 20%
  Critical: 10% (Maximum 26% after Upgrades)
  Stun: 2.8 Seconds (Slow, 2-hit weapon)
  Durability: 15
  Stamina Cost per swing: 2.5
  Purchase Price: 30,000 Gold
  
  Crafting Information:
  Manual Rank: 2
  Materials: Iron Ingot x3, Mythril Ingot x4, Gold Ingot x2
  15% Average Complete per success
  Finishing Materials: 4 Fine Leather Straps, 3 Tough Strings
  Manual Location: Barri Edern's Secret Pass
  
  Unique Upgrades:
  
  Sharpen Edges
  Upgrade 3-3
  Maximum Damage +20
  Minimum Damage +10
  Durability -5
  Critical +10%
  Proficiency: 60, Gold: 15,000
  NPC: Edern
  
  Add Weight
  Upgrade 4-4
  Maximum Damage +20
  Minimum Damage -15
  Balance -20%
  Proficiency: 85, Gold: 30,000
  
  Artisan
  Strength +0~75
  Dexterity -20~50
  Luck -0~25
  HP +5~10
  Proficiency: 100, Gold: 50,000
  NPC: Edern
  
  
  New Dungeon:-
  Barri Edern's Secret
  Obtained via: 'Elen the Fool' Questline
  Quest #1 'Super Secret Stuff'
  [SPOILER=Quest]Quest Details:
  'Hey, so Grandpa keeps disappearing into Barri recently, and he's been making some things that he's not teaching me about. I wanna know what's going on!'
  -Elen
  
  Objectives:
  1. Talk to Elen.
  2. Purchase a [Short Spear] from Edern and take it to Elen.
  3. Purchase a [Halberd] from Edern and take it to Elen.
  4. Use 'Elen's Prototype' Manual to create an item. (Which would be 'Dull Spear', not-equippable)
  5. Take the Dull Spear to Edern.
  
  Rewards: 25,000 Exp
  [/SPOILER]
  
  Quest #2 'Foolish Girl'
  [SPOILER=Quest]Quest Details:
  'So Elen figured out what I was doing, eh? I guess it's time to come clean..'
  -Edern
  
  Objectives:
  1: Talk to Edern.
  2: Bring Edern 5 Mythril Ingots.
  
  Rewards: Barri 'Edern's Secret' Pass, Keyword 'Edern's Secret Pass', 50,000 Exp, 25,000 Gold
  [/SPOILER]
  Use Keyword with Edern for more passes at 5,000 Gold each.
  [/SPOILER]
  
  There's room for improvement, but I'll stop before I really do something wrong. Feel free to add/criticise/remove~
  
  Shit, forgot about that dungeon pass.. gimme 10 minutes to think up a quest to get the pass... (DONE.)
  Forgot something else, you know, WHAT'S ACTUALLY IN THE DUNGEON. 10 more minutes...
  
  [SPOILER=Dungeon]
  Barri 'Edern's Secret' Dungeon:-
  
  Contains spawns from Barri Advanced, and Golems from The Other Alchemists Hard (Stone and Forest).
  
  Spawn Patterns include regular Barri Advanced patterns, plus some spawns of 2-5 Golems.
  
  Boss Room:
  Snow Golem x3 (TOA Elite standard with 2000 more HP, Regular Golem sized)
  Magic Golem (3x stats on Snow Golem, regular golem sized, Tabhartas movement speed and wound rate)
  
  Rewards:
  (Common)
  10,000-15,000 Gold
  Mythril Ingot x5
  Mana Herb
  Short Spear (Base Grade)
  Halberd (Base Grade)
  
  (Rare)
  Blacksmith Manual - Short Spear
  Blacksmith Manual - Halberd
  [/SPOILER]
  
  Hope I haven't missed something else, though I probably have.

  
  
  Maybe...
  Apply default Piercing Level 1 to all Two-Handed weapons.
  
  Two-Handed Mastery adds 1 Piercing at r5, and another at r1
  One-Handed Sword Mastery adds 1 Piercing at r1
  Dual Wield Mastery adds 1 Piercing at r5, and another at r1
  
  And, need I say that Fury and Weak Spot cannot be used with a Lance, and are not race-restrictive.
  
  Aaaand now Fury's Cooldowns look excessively long...
  [SPOILER=Lowered...]

  [Image: http://img191.imageshack.us/img191/4405/mzhm.png]

  
  [/SPOILER]
• alphafox wrote on 2013-10-02 00:17
  - pet revamp [ i want them to be useful for something else other than punching bags and inventory space ] for them to have the ability to scale with the rest of the content for those of us that have them , meaning more damage and def .
  -melee and range adjustments : to keep up with the rest of the content and some new skills on both categories
  -another pet idea the ability to add and train new skills into their repertoire and uncapping of their stats and skills [ i dont care if it costs nx or not as long as its there ]
  - clothing mastery : so we can get some def with our gear and prot
  
  - alchemy : water cannon and other combat related skills staying loaded so as long as you dont click another skill icon in the alchemy skill set . Elemental wave versions of the rest of the alchemy skills watercannon becoming water machine gun or stream , flame burst into firestorm or napalm , sand burst into sand storm , raincasting into god knows what .
  
  -spirit weapons : stat uncap this is self explanatory , more spirit weapon attacks and elimination of the other cooldown and for the damage of the attacks to scale with its own stats even a spirit weapon incarnate summon that attacks in assistance with the player .
  
  -New talent summoner ? : a hybrid of alchemy and magic that lets you summon elemental spirits work with the player or the player controlling the spirit .
  
  
  
  i second that idea of all weapons have special upgrades orginal post by syr
• Silverkun wrote on 2013-10-02 02:11

  Quote from Natural Harmonia Gropius;1154772:

  1) Scrap the piece of shit game engine it has now and rework the game from the ground up to be something worthwhile
  2) Rework dungeons to work similarly to shadow missions, at the very least in method of entry. Increase rewards to make running them worthwhile, be it end reward and possibly monster drops.
  3) Remodel and re-texture some of the old, incredibly shitty hair selections. Doesn't have to be the free hair selections, but some of the premium ones look fucking terrible.
  4) Move away from Solonogi content. Do something to promote the MULTIPLAYER part of MMORPG, which Mabinogi is supposed to be. If I wanted to be a recluse I would play a single player game that would end up being 50x better than Mabi simply because it isn't Mabi.

  
  
  I would like to second all of these opinions, especially #4 and #1.
• Velithen wrote on 2013-10-02 03:04
  I love the idea to make warrior a bit more viable so it's not completely outclassed by lance but i dont want skill to added just for the purpose to add skill with higher multiplier.
  
  first a little buff to windmill, this skill was fine in the earlier days of the game but with all the new skill set released, the little 250% is now nothing, i personnaly only use it for defensive purpose because i dont want to screw up another class AoE.
  
  Windmill 250% -> 350%
  
  
  Instead of an additionnal active skill i'd like to see a new passive skill that embrace the real strong affinity melee has with the Rock,Paper,Scissor system
  
  Opportunity
  Simply put thins skill will trigger an additionnal multiplier if you're using the right skill when the target is "vulnerable"
  Exemple, any attack with "clean hit" will trigger the skill, using smash against defence, attacking a casting mage, using charge against range, windmill against counter, counter against normal, normal against smash and more.
  
  the Other skill would be something a bit like Quinn passive in league of legends, the player would see a target appear on a enemie and if its attack the enemie during this time it would add another mutiplier. Higher rank would make more targets to appear more often and last longer.
  
  This way warrior would only reach dmg close to lance by adding multiplier, where lance would be more a aggresive play style, warrior would be more strategic and defensive, using the right skill and waiting for the right time to strike.
  
  Edit: forgot reduce Defence from str and magic defence from will scaling to 1:20
  
  give giant a new weapon orriented toward tanking to balance this change, a 2h-weapon (Totem) that is a shield and a weapon at the same time, it would ave defensive upgrade up to 5 like any weapon, this way giant can still tank without the ability to deal crazy dmg at the same time
  
  Totem would increase the effectiveness of taunt and stomp ( stomp AoE would become larger and monster close to the giant would get a knockback effect)
  
  Edit 2: change elf hide so it can be used in combat, hide no longer make the elf immune to aggresion, instead mobs will priorize other targets and take longer to notice the hiding elf, additionnaly only 1 mob may notice the elf every 10 sec
  
  Add new healing hybrid weapon, right now there is close to no point to carry a healing wand because party healing is kinda no that much usefull out of some situation.
  
  Weapons like
  Monk handwarp
  healing totems
  Healing shield
  healing mandolin
  Healing Cylinder?
  Healing bow?
  
  i support any idea that make mobs harder